Tribunal
June 20-21 2024
Match Day Reports
Section | Reported Club | Reported Player | Charge | Category | Outcome |
Division 3 Mens | Box Hill North | Alex Williams | Striking another person | 1 | 3-matches |
Division 1 Mens | Preston | Sean Calcedo | Engaging in Rough Conduct | 1 | Charge not sustained |
Premier B Mens | Williamstown | Jai Haines | Engaging in Rough Conduct | 1 | 4-matches |
Premier C Men’s | Hampton Rovers | Josh McPherson | careless contact with an umpire | 1 | Charge not sustained |
Division 2 Womens | Glen Eira | Sarah Fitzpatrick | using abusive language to an umpire | 1 | Charge not sustained |
Premier Mens | Old Xavs | Alex Trigar | Engaging in Rough Conduct | 1 | Charge not sustained |
June 15-16 2024
Match Day Reports
Player | Team | Section | Reportable Offence | Category | Outcome |
Killian Doyle | Old Peninsula | Division 1 Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Karthik Seevanayagam | Old Ivanhoe | Under 19 Division 2 | Using abusive, insulting or obscene language towards or in relation to an Umpire | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Charles Cosgriff | Monash Blues | Premier C Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Mitchell Wooffindin | Old Carey | Premier C Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Tom Yorgey | Old Brighton | Premier Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Ed Michelmore | Old Melburnians | Premier Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 2 matches |
Jamie Roach | Oakleigh | Premier C Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
*Club requested the early guilty plea, resulting in a one (1) match reduction
Melee Charges
William Buck Premier Men’s – Old Xaverians vs Old Scotch
William Buck Premier Men’s – Old Brighton vs Collegians
Premier B Men’s – Old Geelong vs De La Salle
Division 1 Men’s – Ormond vs Old Peninsula
Division 2 Men’s – Bulleen Templestowe vs Wattle Park*
Under 19 Division 2 Men’s – Oakleigh vs Old Trinity*
*Two melees in one match
June 1-2 2024
Match Day Reports
Player | Team | Section | Reportable Offence | Category | Outcome |
Jack Kilgour | Collegians | Under 19 Division 3 | Kicking another person | Category (i) | Charge not sustained |
Koen Chandler | St Bedes/Mentone | Premier B Men’s | Using abusive, insulting or obscene language towards or in relation to an Umpire | Category (i) | Charge not sustained |
Sefton McGraw | De La Salle | Premier B Men’s Reserve | Striking another person | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Miller Chilcott | Old Brighton | Premier Under 19 Men’s | Bumping or making forceful contact with an opponent from front-on when that player has their head down over the football | Category (i) | Charge not sustained |
Lachlan McCluskey | Old Brighton | Premier Under 19 Men’s | Using abusive, insulting or obscene language towards or in relation to an Umpire | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Liam Gillard | Oakleigh | Premier C Men’s | Striking another person | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Martin Gleeson | University Blues | Premier Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | Charge not sustained |
Elliot Atwell | Marcellin | Premier C Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | Charge not sustained |
*Club requested the early guilty plea, resulting in a one (1) match reduction
Melee Charges
William Buck Premier Men’s – St Kevin’s vs Old Brighton
Premier C Men’s – PEGS vs Parkdale
Division 1 Men’s – Old Peninsula vs Prahan
May 25-26 2024
Match Day Reports
Player | Team | Section | Reportable Offence | Category | Outcome |
Adela Michelson | Coburg FC | Premier Women’s | Striking another person | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Hudson Turner | St Bedes/Mentone | Under 19 Division 2 Men’s | Behaving in abusive, insulting, threatening or obscene manner towards Umpire | Category (ii) | 2 matches* |
John Thompson | Mentone Panthers | Thirds Division 2 | Striking another person | Category (ii) | 2 matches* |
Jack Pinder | Caulfield Grammarians | Under 19 Premier Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 4 matches |
Jeremy Simon | Ormond | Division 1 Men’s | Behaving in abusive, insulting, threatening or obscene manner towards Umpire | Category (i) | Charge not sustained |
Felix Dover | Glen Eira | Under 19 Division 1 Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | Charge not sustained |
Angelena Roan | MUWFC | Premier Women’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Raage Noor | Monash Blues | Premier C Reserves Men’s | Striking another person | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Flynn Siassios | Collegians | Premier Reserve Men’s | Behaving in abusive, insulting, threatening or obscene manner towards Umpire | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Drew Pearman | Albert Park | Division 3 Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
*Club requested the early guilty plea, resulting in a one (1) match reduction
Melee Charges
William Buck Premier Men’s – University Blacks vs Old Xaverians
Premier B Men’s – Beaumaris vs St Bedes/Mentone
Under 19 Division 4 Men’s – St Kevin’s vs Old Xaverians
——
May 18-19 2024
Match Day Reports
Player | Team | Section | Reportable Offence | Category | Outcome |
Ned Waters | Kew | Division 1 Men’s | Striking another person | Category (i) | Charge not sustained |
Jules Lohan | Old Brighton | Under 19 Premier Men’s | Tripping another person | Category (ii) | 2 matches |
Mitchell Alexander | Williamstown CYMS | Under 19 Premier Men’s | Tripping another person | Category (ii) | 2 matches |
Spencer Zahra | North Brunswick | Division 3 Men’s | Striking another person | Category (i) | 2 matches |
Charles Holmes | Old Xaverians | Premier Men’s | Bumping another person | Category (i) | Charge not sustained |
Brittney Gray | Old Yarra Cobras | Premier Women’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | Charge not sustained |
*Club requested the early guilty plea, resulting in a one (1) match reduction
Melee Charges
Premier C Men’s – Oakleigh vs PEGS
Division 1 Men’s – Kew vs Parkside
Division 3 Men’s – Power House vs North Brunswick
Under 19 Premier Men’s – University Blues vs St Kevin’s
May 11-12 2024
Match Day Reports
Player | Team | Section | Reportable Offence | Category | Outcome |
Jake Ryder | St Bedes/Mentone Tigers | Premier B Men’s | Striking another person | Category (i) | Charge not sustained |
Darra Conlon | Power House | Division 3 Men’s Reserve | Intentionally making contact with an umpire | Category (ii) | 8 matches |
Sonny Martino | Glen Eira/Old Mckinnon | Under 19 Division 1 Men’s | Spitting on or at another person | Category (ii) | 2 matches |
Luke Perrone | Marcellin | Premier C Men’s | Striking another person | Category (i) | 3 matches |
Douglas Lawrence | Old Scotch | Premier Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Luke McCleary | Collegians | Premier Men’s | Striking another person | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Eli Taylor | Old Carey | Premier C Men’s | Striking another person | Category (i) | Charge not sustained |
Henry Woolcock | University Blues | Under 19 Premier Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | Charge not sustained |
Christian Carnovale | Hampton Rovers | Premier C Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | Charge not sustained |
Sean Fisher | De La Salle | Premier B Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 2 matches |
Hugh Nicholason | De La Salle | Premier B Men’s | Striking another person | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Thomay Nicolaou | West Brunswick | Premier Women’s | Striking another person | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Joel Clare | Box Hill North | Division 3 Men’s Reserve | Striking another person | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
*Club requested the early guilty plea, resulting in a one (1) match reduction
Melee Charges
William Buck Premier Men’s – St Bernards vs Old Scotch
William Buck Premier Men’s – Old Xaverians vs Old Brighton
Division 2 Men’s – Bulleen Templestowe vs Aquinas
May 4-5 2024
Match Day Reports
Player | Team | Section | Reportable Offence | Category | Outcome |
Connor Brugeaud | South Melbourne Districts | Division 2 Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 4 matches |
Karan Bharathi | St Bernards | William Buck Premier Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 3 matches |
Aaron Ivak | Old Xaverians | Premier U19 Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Ed Dalton | Old Xaverians | Premier U19 Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Harvey | Caulfield Grammarians | Premier B Men’s | Striking another person | Category (i) | 3 matches |
Jack Ferraro | St Bedes/Mentone Tigers | Premier B Men’s | Striking another person | Category (i) | Charge not sustained |
*Club requested the early guilty plea, resulting in a one (1) match reduction
Melee Charges
Division 1 Men’s – Old Yarra Cobras vs Ormond
Under 19 Division 3 – Ormond vs St Bernards
Under 19 Division 4 Men’s – St Kevin’s vs MHSOB
APRIL 27 – 28 2024
Match Day Reports
Player | Team | Section | Reportable Offence | Category | Outcome |
Jack Behnk | St Bedes/Mentone Tigers | Premier B Men’s | Behaving in abusive, insulting, threatening or obscene manner towards Umpire | Category (i) | 3 matches |
Ethan Sherlock | Mazenod | Premier C Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (ii) | 5 matches |
Lachlan Myers | Glen Eira/Old Mckinnon | Premier C Men’s | Striking another person | Category (i) | 3 matches |
Angus Murphy | Bulleen Templestowe | Division 2 Reserves Men’s | Behaving in abusive, insulting, threatening or obscene manner towards Umpire | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Mia Weekes | MUWFC | William Buck Premier Reserves Women’s | Kicking another person | Category (i) | 3 matches* |
Max Herzel | AJAX | Premier C Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Luke Winter | St Kevin’s | William Buck Premier Men’s | Carelessly interfering with an Umpire | Category (i) | Charge not sustained |
*Club requested the early guilty plea, resulting in a one (1) match reduction
Melee Charges
Under 19 Premier Men’s – University Blues vs Williamstown
Under 19 Division 1 Men’s – Fitzroy vs Old Carey
Under 19 Division 1 Men’s – Old Trinity vs Old Xaverians
APRIL 20 – 21 2024
Match Day Reports
Player | Team | Section | Reportable Offence | Category | Outcome |
Angus Edgar | Old Brighton | William Buck Premier Reserve Men’s | Striking another person | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
James Gottschalk | Prahran | Division 1 Men’s | Striking another person | Category (i) | 4 matches |
James Braddy | Old Scotch | William Buck Premier Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | Charge not sustained |
Chris Pietsch | Caulfield Grammarians | Under 19 Division 4 Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Riley Turner | Old Carey | Premier C Reserve Men’s | Striking another person | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Bradley Higgins | De La Salle | Premier B Reserves Men’s | Behaving in abusive, insulting, threatening or obscene manner towards Umpire | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Tom Furphy | Old Geelong | Premier B Men’s | Tripping another person | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Louis Vescio | University Blacks | William Buck Premier Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | Charge not sustained |
*Club requested the early guilty plea, resulting in a one (1) match reduction
Melee Charges
Premier C Men’s – Oakleigh vs Mazenod
Division 1 Men’s – West Brunswick vs Preston Bullants
APRIL 12 – 13 2024
Match Day Reports
Player | Team | Section | Reportable Offence | Category | Outcome |
Oscar Tilley | Glen Eira/Old McKinnon | Under 19 Division 1 Men’s | Using abusive, insulting or obscene language towards or in relation to an Umpire | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Oscar McMaster | Beaumaris | Premier B Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 2 matches* |
Ruby Barnes | Williamstown CYMS | Premier B Women’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | Category (i) | 3 matches |
*Club requested the early guilty plea, resulting in a one (1) match reduction
Melee Charges
Under 19 Premier Men’s – St Bede/Mentone Tigers v Williamstown CYMS
Under 19 Division 1 Men’s – Hampton Rovers v Glen Eira/Old McKinnon
Under 19 Division 2 Men’s – St Bede/Mentone Tigers v Mazenod
Premier B Men’s – Old Ivanhoe v Old Camberwell
Premier B Men’s – Old Haileybury v Old Trinity (2) *
Premier Men’s – Old Melburnians v Collegians
*Two individual melees during this match
CARRY OVER FROM 2023
Player | Team | Section | Reportable Offence | Matches to Serve |
Angus Corke | Old Brighton | Under 19 Premier Mens | Striking another person | 1 match to serve |
Simon Richards | St Bedes/Mentone | Premier B Mens | Engaging in Rough Conduct | 1 match to serve |
Hugh Morris-Dalton | Fitzroy | Premier Thirds Mens | Engaging in Rough Conduct | 2 matches to serve |
Jake Phillips | Old Scotch | Under 19 Premier Mens | Striking another person | 1 match to serve |
Justin Krok | Hampton Rovers | Premier C Men’s | Disputing a decision of an umpire | 1 match to serve |
Michael Fogale | Preston Bullants | Division 1 Men’s | Striking another person | 2 matches to serve |
Otto Ishak | Fitzroy | Thirds Division 1 Mens | Striking another person | 2 matches to serve |
Joel Matherson | Prahran | Division 1 Reserves Mens | Using abusive, insulting or obscene language towards or in relation to an Umpire | 2 matches to serve |
Jackson Browne | Brunswick | Division 2 Mens | Engaging in Rough Conduct | 1 match to serve |
Lloyd Evans | Oakleigh | Division 1 Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | 1 match to serve |
Sean Howard | Wattle Park | Division 3 Men’s | Engaging in Rough Conduct | 2 matches to serve |
Luke Kerr | Prahran | Division 1 Men’s | Striking another person | 2 matches to serve |
Kevin Tutty | South Melbourne Districts | Division 2 Reserve Mens | Striking another person | 2 matches to serve |
Zachary Ginies | St Kevins | Premier Reserves Mens | Engaging in Rough Conduct | 2 matches to serve |
Ethan Harvey | Hawthorn | Division 3 Men’s | Bumping/Forceful Front-On Contact | 2 matches to serve |
William Lewis | Old Brighton | Premier Mens | Striking | 1 match to serve |
Alexander Cincotta | Preston Bullants | Division 1 Mens | Kicking | 3 matches to serve |
Justin Raiti | Hawthorn | Division 3 Mens | Striking | 1 match to serve |
Georgia Wyett | Kew | Premier Reserves Womens | Striking | 3 matches to serve |
Brandon Efron | AJAX | Premier B Mens | Tripping | 1 match to serve |
Catherine O’Bryan | Coburg | Premier Womens | Engaging in Rough Conduct | 2 matches to serve |
Ethan Hall | St Bedes/Mentone | Under 19 Premier Mens | Striking another person | 2 matches to serve |
Ashley Evans | Albert Park | Division 4 Mens | Striking another person | 4 matches to serve |